Appeals for Help from 2016
Photo of Brass Band in Front of Hills -
- Does Anyone Have Any Information?
- 19 May 2016
John Bean (Thirsk) sent us the photograph opposite which he thought might of interest. (Click on it for larger image)
He had made enquiries to the Eston Residents Association several years ago but receivd no reply.
John has no idea when or where the photo was taken.
But he thinks it must have a connection with this area as the hill in the background has the outline of the Eston Hills. Also on the reverse of the photo is printed -
"S.Kruger, Photographer, South Eston, Middlesbrough"
John does not remember ever hearing any mention of a band in Eston, but there seems to have been one!
Perhaps it was a visiting band - but the location for the photo seems strange?
If it was an Eston band then a question arises - the men would have been manual workers and so poorly paid - their instruments would not have been cheap even in those days - so who paid for the instruments?
Probably the band was supported by a large organisation and so John supposes it was the mines and associated steelworks.
John guesses that the date of the photo is late 19th century when many bands were supported by industrial groups.
So John asks whether anyone can identify the band or the location or add to his thoughts?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
6 December 2016 - from Webmaster:
First my apologies for not listing this Appeal on our website until over 6 months after John raised it in May.
I did circulate an enlargement of John’s photo with his queries at our group’s May meeting.
Unfortunately no-one recognised the band - but several thought the hills in the background were probably our Eston Hills!
There could be some houses on the left of the picture (though might just be markings on the photo). If so someone thought it may well have been taken below the Eston Hills nearer Eston rather than from Normanby.
Some of the instruments are most unusual - does anyone know what they are?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 January 2017 - Reply received from Jim Stone:
I have been around brass music for 70 years and still play the euphonium and baritone but nowadays mainly to amuse myself.
Apparently there was a band in Normanby in the 1870s so this photo might be significant - Normanby Brass Band is listed on the Internet Bandsman's Everything Within website (ibew.org.uk).
There were also two brass bands in Eston ie Eston Miners Old and Eston Miners.
The IBEW website says:-
"Eston Miners' Old Brass Band (Middlesbrough) was active from the 1880s to the 1920s. It took part in the ceremony to lay the foundation stones of the Normanby Methodist Church on Saturday June 30th, 1900."
The photo shows what I would call a traditional Village Band or some might say a Scratch Band. They have obviously marched to the hills as the bass drummer has a carrying halter strapped under his coat and the event might be to provide music for a church picnic or Sunday school treat. Who knows?
The instruments I see as left to right:
1.tenor horn/baritone, 2.valve trombone, 3.ophicleide,
4.cornet, 5.cornet?, 6.cornet,
7,(boy), 8.(bystander), 9.cornet,
10.flute or fife?, 11.????, 12.clarinet Eb? or oboe?,
13.side drum, 14.trumpet/long cornet?, 15.euphonium,
16.althorn?, 17.Eb? Bass or bombardon, 18.bass drum.
I hope that my information is of benefit to someone in your group and I enjoy looking at your excellent website.
---------Regards, Jim Stone (Redcar)----------
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
from WebMaster: thanks Jim for your useful comments.
Perhaps the photo was taken after the ceremony laying the foundation stone of our Normanby Methodist Church?
Wonder if there was a newspaper report?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
22 March 2017 - Reply received from Eric Barker:
My grandad Isaac Atkinson Barker played trombone in the band pictured in the Pancrack film ''A Century in Stone''.
In your Message Board I see mention of a band photo in Jim Stones message of 1 January 2017 - but cannot see it!
Keep up the good work. I am still following your website.
-----------Regards, Eric Barker (Stoke)-----------
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
from WebMaster: Thanks Eric for sending that information.
I have fixed the display issue of the band photo on our Message Board - sorry about that!
However you can display a larger version of this photo via that on this Appeals page (but not on the Message Board pages - a technical problem! Problem since resolved - so can now display large versions of the small images on the Message Board!).
I hope you can then confirm whether he is your grandfather?
The only player identified as a trombonist (by Jim Stone) is reasonably clear for a scan from what was such a small photo.
Apparently there were a few brass-bands in the Eston-Normanby area. Do you know which band your grandad played in?
Can you please send us any extra info on your grandad that we could add to our website?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
11 April 2017 - Follow up by Eric Barker:
I can now see the picture on the Appeals page and my grandfather is not on that one.
I always assumed (rightly or wrongly) that the band that my grandad played in was the Eston Miner’s "Silver" band.
I attach a couple of photos of two silver bands showing my grandad. (Click on these for larger images)
The first picture (see opposite) shows my grandfather Isaac Atkinson Barker and his trombone in the middle at the front between the red lines. This is actually a snip from the
Pancrack film
"A Century in Stone"
where the speaker says
"we used to go onto the hills to watch the siver miners band...". So I assume that it is not a brass band.
The second photo opposite shows my grandfather again - this time just to the left of the bass drum. Judging by his medals this is obviously post-WW1. The large house behind could be Wilton Castle.
-----------Regards, Eric Barker (Stoke)-----------
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
12 April 2017 - from WebMaster:
We eventually found a newspaper report about the ceremony to lay the original chapel foundation stone in the
North-Eastern Daily Gazette of 2 July 1900
Unfortunately there are no photographs!
But there are three possibly relevant references:
"A deputation, accompanied by the Eston Miners’ Old Brass Band, met Mr. and Mrs A. E. Pease at Normanby and the party proceeded to the site of the new chapel where a short devotional service was held."
"[Mr.Pease saying] ...he hardly expected to be welcomed by the Eston Band"
"At the conclusion of the ceremony a public tea was held in an adjoining field"
So it is possible that the old photograph was taken of the Eston Miners’ Old Brass Band in the field after the ceremony - but we’ll probably never know for sure!
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
25 February 2018 - Follow up by Ron Kerrison:
My father, Tom Kerrison, wrote many notes on his life in Eston, including names of musicians in his various band photographs.
His writing deteriorated as he approached his 98th birthday (as did his memory perhaps) but on the reverse of his photo of the Eston Miners Silver Band he wrote the names of those he knew.
[Click on our photo shown opposite for larger image]
The order of names may be incorrect.
BACK ROW, LEFT TO RIGHT:-
1.Reuben English, 2.Taff Seymour, 3.Shep Meadows,
4.Bill Armstrong, 5.'Spot' Blot, 6.Bill (box hat),
7.Tommy Dixon, 8.Dan Kilvington,
9.(don't know first-name) King,
10.(another?) Tommy Dixon (Wesley Y.C.)
MIDDLE ROW LEFT TO RIGHT:-
1.Drummer Tewson, 2.(don't know), 3.Nesbet,
4.(don't know), 5.Jack Chapman (-leader),
6.Charlie 'Digby' Kay, (no record of the rest!)
FRONT ROW LEFT TO RIGHT:
1.Nelson, 2.Jack Colman, 3.IKE BARKER,
4.Topsy Cook (trombone), 5.(don't know), 6.Arty Allday,
7.Billy Colman (I think!).
'Spot' was the nickname for many of the Blott families in California, Eston. In fact Tom's 'marra' or co-worker in the pit was always called 'Spot'. He lived in East Row, California and was married to nurse Blott a popular local nurse.
Best Regards,
--------Ron Kerrison (Danby, Nr.Whitby, N.Yorkshire)--------
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
WebMaster (28 February 2018):
Thanks Ron for relating your dad's notes - if only more people wrote details on the back of their photos!
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
If you have any more information
regarding this photo or local bands -
- then please
contact us !
Index of Appeals for Help
One of the main functions of the group is to research the history of the area and provide help for those trying to find answers to their queries. Full details of Appeals for help can be found via links below.
Appeals from 2023:-
update- 18 Sep 2023 --- BACON Family of Church Lane - Any Information ?
update- 20 Mar 2023 --- Does anyone know of Eston Railway Crossing ?
Appeals from 2022:-
update--- 9 Jan 2023 --- Does anyone know of the Normanby pub "Brown Jug" ?
Appeals from 2021:-
new----- 29 Mar 2021 --- Snowdon Family of Ormesby - does anyone know of them?
Appeals from 2020:-
update---21 Feb 2022 --- Normanby Fish Man - does anyone remember him?
Appeals from 2019:-
update---28 Apr 2019 --- Normanby Patent Slag Manure - does anyone know of this?
update---26 Jan 2019 --- Photo of Eston County Modern Dinner Ladies
Appeals from 2018:-
update--- 7 Apr 2018 --- Normanby School - Dinners and Logbook?
Appeals from 2016:-
update---28 Feb 2018 --- Photo of Brass Band in Front of Hills - which band & where is it?
new------ 1 Aug 2016 --- Photos of Normanby Brickyards Employees - names? when taken?
Appeals from 2015:-
update---22 Sep 2015 --- Find at Normanby School of Stone Plaque - where from?
Appeals from 2014:-
update---10 Oct 2014 --- Boundary Marker Stone Inscription - what do the letters represent?
Appeals from 2013:-
update---12 Feb 2015 --- Watson's Yard - where was it?
Appeals from 2012:-
new------ 7 June 2012 --- Walter Baker of Normanby - any memories or information?
Appeals from 2011:-
update---11 Nov 2011 --- Mystery of the Normanby Hall Stones - what were they for?
update---17 Feb 2014 --- Photo of Normanby Miners - who are they?
new------30 Apr 2011 --- Saint Helen's Church - any photos? any stones in your garden?
new------14 Mar 2011 --- Photo of Dixon Street - direction? any corner shops? buildings opposite?
new------14 Mar 2011 --- Laird Street Photo Wanted
new------10 Mar 2011 --- Your Family History Research - what have you found?